
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (AP) -- Florida Insurance Commissioner Kevin McCarty on Wednesday suspended Allstate companies from writing new automobile insurance policies in Florida for refusing to comply fully with a subpoena from the state. McCarty abruptly ended a scheduled two-day meeting after just two hours on Tuesday, angered that Allstate officials failed to turn over information the state requested on hurricane and other property coverage rates - describing the state's request as "irrelevant."
"Florida will no longer be held hostage by this company and its practices," McCarty said.
Allstate's car insurance business is worth about $1.9 billion annually, regulators said. "We're going to hit 'em where it hurts," McCarty said. "We're going to get their attention." Allstate is Florida's second-largest auto insurer with 13 percent of the market in 2006. State Farm is the state's largest with a 19 percent.
Regulators sought property insurance documents relating to Allstate's reinsurance program and its relationship with risk modeling companies, insurance trade associations and insurance rating organizations, but instead received a 51-page letter of objections.
"In view of Allstate's ongoing, blatant disregard of our subpoenas, I have little choice," McCarty said. "Suspending their certificate of authority to write new business in our state should make my point." He said the suspension would be lifted when Allstate fully complies with the state's subpoena. Allstate has reduced its risk on homeowners coverage in recent years while maintaining an aggressive posture in the highly profitable auto insurance market.
McCarty said existing policyholders will not be affected. Allstate must continue to service its clients and must make all required statutory filings including, annual and quarterly financial statements and rate filings. "We have not yet received an order and are evaluating our options," Allstate spokesman Adam Shores said Wednesday. "At this time, it is not clear how this action will affect Allstate or the more than 1,100 Allstate agents in Florida."
The suspension applies to Allstate Insurance Co., Allstate Indemnity Co. and Allstate Property and Casualty Co. "I think the message to the industry nationwide and in the state is not good," said Bob Lotane, spokesman for the Florida Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors, an industry trade association. "The industry has to keep its promises to its policyholders in the wake of catastrophes." The Legislature passed a measure (HB 1A) in special session a year ago to provide some relief to the industry with an eye toward lowering premiums.
The legislation increased the state's Hurricane Catastrophe Fund to provide private insurers with low-cost reinsurance so they could pass along those savings to customers, but Allstate instead sought double-digit increases and regulators wanted answers.
"We cannot tolerate a company determining the scope and depth of an investigation in an area as significant as potential collusion to violate house bill 1-A," McCarty said. "The no kidding rule is in effect."
By BRENT KALLESTAD Associated Press Writer
kevin@4cornersbusinesscouncil.com